Star Scouts, by Mike Lawrence

[mrissa]

Review copy provided by First Second Books.

Some kids’ books are really everybody books, but we call them kids’ books because they’re the first ones kids can read on their own. And other kids’ books lose some of their charm and appeal with exposure. This is the latter kind.

Star Scouts is the same plot as basically every scouting camp story: kid at camp competes with mean kid, both learn lessons about themselves, mean kid turns out to have at least one teamwork moment beneath mean façade, everyone wins (but really mostly the protagonist). The trappings of this version are jetpacks, robotics, and transporters rather than tents, forests, and canoes, but there are no unexpected twists. None whatsoever. And lots and lots of fart jokes, butt jokes, etc.

I like my socialization not to be gender segregated, and I did as a kid, so the integrated nature of Star Scouts feels like it should be cool. Instead…instead a little Earth girl leaves an all-girl organization that is entirely focused on makeup, pop songs, and boys to join a male-headed troop that gets to build and learn. At least this time she’s not the token girl…but there’s basically no redeeming value in the all-female organization; it is clearly supposed to be vapid and horrible and generally worse in every way. Considering what a great experience I had with Girl Scouts and with an all-female 4H troop, and how often “girl stuff” is mapped to “stupid stuff” in nerd circles, do not pass go, do not collect etc., this leaves a slightly sour taste in my mouth. But there’s nothing actually wrong with this graphic novel, and the protagonist is Indian-American, so I’m sure there are some people who will be happy to find representation even in a very formulaic story. Maybe especially then: kids of color are allowed typical kid stories, too. Even when it’s hard to argue against awesome kid stories instead.

Please consider using our link to buy Star Scouts from Amazon.

Originally published at Novel Gazing Redux

Comments

[netmouse.livejournal.com]

Interesting. Rosie's Grandma just sent her Rotten School, by R. L. Stine, one of those partly illustrated early chapter books, and it was unremittingly awful. I'm returning some other things from that lot anyway, so I'm returning it. Girl characters were either pursued or pursuing, the one woman was a totally clueless awful dorm mother, the bad kid is just completely totally bad, and the protagonist is almost completely awful too. Other kids are just there to be manipulated --friends the new kid moves in and "steals" by giving them the old kid's candy bars, and that includes the only kid drawn with dark skin. Utter garbage.

--Netmouse